Most humane form of death penalty?

[Ebaum]

Most humane form of death penalty?


I'd have to go with lethal injection.

[Enlightened One]

Putting someone or something to death is humane? There are unavoidable deaths, and that's acceptable (in my opinion) But going with the topic I would have to say gas/lethal, because both shut down the nervous and resp system and you just drift off.

[Vlad]

What form of death penalty should we use then?

[USMC the Almighty]

Firing squad.

[Nammy]

I don't see how that's more humane than any other forms of death penalty.

[USMC the Almighty]

I don't see how that's more humane than any other forms of death penalty.

I guess it's not. But if I were going to be executed (knock on wood) -- I would take the firing squad. No question.

[Enlightened One]

I think having my heart blown out of my back is a little less than savory, But that and the guillotine is probably the fastest and most painless way to meet whatever place waits for you..

[Nammy]

I don't think that guillotine is the fastest and most painless...

[Enlightened One]

I don't think that guillotine is the fastest and most painless...

Why? The body's nerve receptors all go through the brain, and the body and head are seperated.. Feeling no pain and instant death, that's humane right? The actual method is ratherly barbaric, and messy, I suppose the overall method is not to humane, but it's 0-death in less than a second.

[vyo476]

Why? The body's nerve receptors all go through the brain, and the body and head are seperated.. Feeling no pain and instant death, that's humane right? The actual method is ratherly barbaric, and messy, I suppose the overall method is not to humane, but it's 0-death in less than a second.

It's also far easier to botch lethal injection. Just look at the Tookie Williams case. I'd go with the guillotine. No pain, no feeling at all actually, and the thing costs next to nothing to maintain.

That's if I was in favor of capital punishment, which I'm not.

[Eternal]

it is not clear whether the guillotine was as painless as it was intended to be. i would much rather go for some delusional method where you can't even tell you are dying.

if none really exists, then just to be laid down on some giant metal plate and be squished by another giant plate in a split second--the human pancake maker.

[vyo476]

it is not clear whether the guillotine was as painless as it was intended to be. i would much rather go for some delusional method where you can't even tell you are dying.

if none really exists, then just to be laid down on some giant metal plate and be squished by another giant plate in a split second--the human pancake maker.

So you're split between Batman and b-movie?

[Freethinker]

Most humane form of death penalty?


I'd have to go with lethal injection.

How about natural causes From old age in prison?

[vyo476]

How about natural causes From old age in prison?

Old age in prison tends to mean you've been there for a while (unless you're one of those dangerous 80 year old murderers - watch out for them!). That's not a terribly pleasant experience - many would prefer to just get bumped off rather than spend forty years in prison with nothing but bars, three stone walls, three awful meals a day, and the strong possibly of getting ass-raped by one of the other inmates.

This whole thing has gotten me thinking - why, in the name of whatever deity you happen to believe in, do we bother talking about how "humane" these things are? No matter what option is selected for someone who has committed a serious crime, chances are it's going to be "inhumane." Toss a guy in prison and all that stuff listed above is going to happen to him and that's supposed to be more "humane" than just killing him?

I don't really understand all this talk about humane forms of execution, either. I mean, it's not like the guy whose getting killed is going to complain, right? And his relatives - well, what's their excuse? "His last moments shouldn't have been so painful." Think of it this way - he isn't in any pain now, right? "It was more painful for us to have to watch him suffer." Well then...don't watch! Executions should not be public affairs and they certainly shouldn't be attended by the family of whoever is getting killed. I mean, what do you say to your relatives in that position? "Come on, Johnny, time to go watch Daddy's life end! Don't forget to tie your shoes!" You want inhumane? Inhumane is allowing the people closest to the convict to watch his/her death. Let him see his family before you kill him, sure, but don't let them watch. Can you say "psychological trauma"?

[Dave]

I think the type of sentence imposed should fit the crime. The death penalty should only be as humane as it was for the victims of the person sentenced.

[OPGhostdog]

Personally, A person who robs or steal has the death wish on his
or herself. The death wish can be a form of the Death Penalty,
and can be served by other means. Here's a example...Let's say
a guy robs and shoot a handicap Eldder, and someone comes
along (like me), and witness this crime in progress. As a street
hood I can administrate the penality on the spot by blowing the
crook's brains out for the crime that was just committed.

I am sure that we are not talking about the death penality from
that viewpoint, but it does happen in everyday life, and I believe
in two old saying. (1): Live by the sword...die by the sword, and
my 2nd is Think twice before you might have to pay the price.

As far as Justice being served..it takes to long. Most prisoners
who is on death row usually spends many many years before
being juiced. To long to wait for taking someone's life.

In the Samurai Code of Ethic. it explains about the death unto
ye who does wrong and get caught. Political Ghostdog