Well at least we can agree that evil doesn't exist within the bounds of our definition of the word.
I find no reference to the "circles of Hell" that is in the least clear. Hell is an allegorical place, whereas a circle is simply a line of no depth going around a point in space forever.
I love your dramatic little "sighs", they're so sweet and long suffering.
This YOU call soul, I know Christians who call it spirit. Your logic sags down a bit here though. The fact that we exist does not necessarily mean that part of us is independent of the material existence. We assume that it does, but there is no proof of it--like all religion it's based on belief or faith or wishful thinking. I don't actually disagree with your definition, but I do know that it's not proven in any way.
So, present a metaphysical proof, a bigtime science guy like you should have all kinds of metaphysical proofs. I am unaware of any metaphysical "proofs". People believe things, but that's not proof.
It's a metaphysical truth, so why are you demanding an empirical proof? I would expect that on some other discussion site, but not this one.
