Reply to thread

We are not pro-torture... We simply disagree that waterboarding is torture.



Too bad you cannot do the same...


Labeling us "Pro-Torture" is itself a red herring and an ad hominem attack on our character, both informal fallacies of logic. The label is further fallacious because you've come to the conclusion based on a formal, Propositional fallacy.


Since you have no idea what any of that means, let me explain:


Rob says Waterboarding is NOT torture

Top Gun says Waterboarding IS torture

Therefore Top Gun has concluded that Rob supports all forms of torture.


We are against torture, We're not pro-torture...


Consider us "Pro-Choice" on the issue of waterboarding.


We just disagree that our use of waterboarding constitutes torture....


Perhaps I should start referring to your position on Abortion as Pro-Infanticide rather than Pro-Choice... Although it would be fallacious of me to do so.


Back
Top