Reply to thread

A sales tax would be too high of a percentage to replace the income tax. This conclusion comes from a simple arithmetic, but still, I may have missed something.


The total income tax revenue for 2008 was $1.03 Trillion

The total amount Americans spent was $4.4 T. (US Census Bureau)

The percent sales tax to equal the income tax would be 1.03/4.4 = 23.4%.

The total government receipts was $2.17 T, which means 1.14 T came from other revenue sources. I will assume that is the same.


So the conclusion is that if we were to replace income tax with a sales tax, the sales tax would have to be 23.4%.  That's way too high.  It shows what we already guessed that the poor buy a lot more stuff as a percentage of their income than the wealthy. The average household spends 78% of their income.


Back
Top