Yes, it's a federal issue, and yes, the fed is failing, and has been for decades. Maybe if enough states begin to take matters into their own hands, the federal government will finally and at long last begin to do what it takes to protect national sovereignty.
Put politics aside and do what is logically possible and fair? Do what works, and political ideology be damned? The federal government will do that when pigs fly, Hell freezes, and San Francisco goes Republican, or maybe just when enough of the states begin to take over the problem themselves.
well first you need to accept that fact that, no we are not going to Deport everyone...That is a fantasy and not going to happen...to hard to do, and business would hate it, and people would get mad when all of the sudden there food costs and other areas jump up on them..or we have shortages.
those here now Illegal, you set up a system to get them into the system and at some point legal...provided they have no major criminal record...and you fine them for breaking the law to enter...those with major criminal records, you deport or jail.
we force employers to only hire legal workers...this would be be set up with enough time for companies to make sure there workers are legal, and for people to get a legal visa or green card. A better and universal system would be set up to verify legal status. this means you have to have something like a secure card to verify ...to those who are scared of big brother...you can get immigration reform, or we can just open the border...if you don't want a way to check..then whats the point of the law.
we tighten the border security. this means more people, and more high tech,.....sorry but the build a well idea fails in many ways...the biggest being....the wall does not stop people...Penn and Teller did a nice thing on this before...had 6 illegals build a wall...to spec of what is being used....then had them get in groups of 2...and where given the most basic of tools, a wire cutter and small shovel....and timed what group would win, the one that went over...under, or threw....who one is not important key is all did in like 2 min or less. Unless we want some super wall that no one will want to pay for and would take many years to build, its not going to work as a key part of the security...
the biggest key will be in cutting off the reason to come here...jobs...also we should do our best to help Mexico become a nation where it can offer jobs to its people...this will mean major Help on the Drug battle there...and the just as deadly but not talked about heavy flow of legal US guns into Mexico for drug lords to feed the killing.
In my view, this as good as your going to get with being realistic about what will actually pass as law, and what is physically possible. Its not perfect, but fact is its not going to be....no one agrees on what perfect is.