Reply to thread

I don't know the level in dollar figures -- my arguement is simply if you can borrow it for basically nothing -- you are not nearing a collapse.

 

To make your argument stick however (That invading Iran will collapse the nation) -- you need to determine that figure, and explain why such an invasion will get us there.

 


 

All of this is true -- and none of it backs up your original assertion.  Your argument is that invading Iran will collapse the country -- because of overspending.  Nothing you state above makes the link.

 

I have argued on the other hand that such action would probably not be above the range of a 30% shock to oil prices -- and we have seen such prices before and survivied.

 



I agree in theory -- but look around -- reality is not bearing it out.  Our inflation rate is not through the roof, we continue to have positive growth, the demand for dollars at 2% shows that the dollars is not in any real danger as of now as being replaced -- can all of this ultimately happen?  Sure -- is it happening now?  Not really.



 

We have a ways to go before we get to that stage -- and I just don't buy that the invasion of Iran gets us there.  How much do you envision this war will cost?  $2 trillion over a decade?  Will $200 billion more a year sink us?  That is what you are claiming?

 


 

"Shifting us into a higher gear" is not collapse.  Yes we spend a ton of money -- far too much -- but we can reverse that at this point.

 

 

 

Possibly -- possibly not.  The good thing about "delay" is that we can let the scenario play out instead of blindly jumping in.


Back
Top