I have been watching the Senate debate the Webb Amendment. Rotating the troops on a one for one basis seems fair to me. If you are in Iraq for fifteen months, you get fifteen months at home before going back for another tour. Who could honestly argue with that? Funny to watch nervous senators spout some nonsense about micro managing the war. All the senators who are combat veterans, both Democrat and Republican are in favor of the amendment. The Bush administration is breaking the all volunteer force.