If only every Republican and Conservative were as logical and rational as yourself our country would be in much better shape. I'm saddened that so few Conservatives have come to terms with such a simple and obvious truth. It's a problem Republicans and Conservatives (in general) don't seem to grasp...
If you concede that any amount of forced redistribution is good, then there is no objective basis for opposing greater degrees of redistributive policy, it becomes entirely subjective. Dems always claim they have the moral high ground when they seek to expand forced redistrubtion and the Republicans, who oppose those expansions, are left without a moral defense of their position because they've abandoned morality entirely by agreeing with the morality of the welfare state in the first place.
Is it moral to take, by threat of force, the fruits of one mans labor and give it to another man who has not earned it and does not deserve it? Of course not, it's immoral, it's legalized theft, it is slavery by degree. Opposition to policies of forced redistribution is the moral high ground. Once the Republicans agreed with the Dems that it IS moral to forcibly redistributed X amount of wealth, there is no argument they can make for why it's less moral, rather than more moral, to allow Y or Z levels of forced redistribution. Democrats will always win that argument and, worse yet, get the "moral" credit for being the more compassionate party.